Evaluation of Additively Manufactured Ultrahard Steels
Recent advances in both alloy development and additive manufacturing have enabled the production of ultrahigh-strength steels in near net shape parts.

Ultrahigh-strength steels are traditionally defined as those steels with a minimum yield strength of approximately 1380 MPa. Notable examples of steels in this category include AISI 4130, AISI 4140, and AISI 4340. In many cases, maximizing the performance of these alloys requires a rather complex approach that involves a series of tempering, annealing, or stress-relieving treatments. As a result, they are produced using a variety of traditional processing methods such as casting, rolling, extrusion, or forging. These traditional methods — combined with the ultrahigh strength of the steels — often meant that the production of complex, near-net shape parts of high quality was quite difficult. In addition, these production methods often entailed repetitive treatments or long production cycles, both of which resulted in elevated production costs.
Additive manufacturing (AM, also known as 3D printing) has recently been recognized as a manufacturing method that enables the production of near-net shape parts. In these methods, a complex part is iteratively built in a layer-by-layer process that involves powder deposition followed by selective melting/sintering of the powder to form the part. With the continued development of processing lasers, it is now possible to form fully dense components from a wide range of metals powders, including refractory alloys, steels, and other high-temperature alloys.
Furthermore, parts produced by 3D printing often require less finishing work, which results in faster production cycles and potentially significant cost savings. Furthermore, the metal powder not incorporated into the part is often reclaimed and, after a cleaning protocol that involves sieving and removal of agglomerates, can be used in the next build operation. This ability to “reuse” the metal powder also offers appreciable cost savings relative to the scrap waste produced by the casting and machining of larger metal blocks to final parts.
Although there is great potential associated with the AM of ultrahigh-strength steel components, there are also significant challenges that must be addressed, typically on an alloy-by-alloy basis. For example, many of these steels have highly complex compositions (e.g., multiple alloying elements) that are intended to form a desired range of strengthening precipitates or phases. Due to their broad compositional range, it can be quite challenging to understand, predict, and/or control the interaction between the laser energy and metal powder during the printing process.
As a result, it often requires a prolonged investigation and process optimization routine to achieve the desired microstructure in the final, printed component. Other factors that must also be addressed to achieve high-quality parts are the removal of property dependence on build direction, high residual stresses, and undesired microstructural features such as pores and/or cracks. From even this brief consideration, it is clear that the production of high-quality parts using AM is not a trivial process, but it typically involves many hours of part building and evaluation to develop the desired process parameters.
An effort was undertaken to acquire and evaluate a series of ultrahigh strength steels produced by VBN Components (Uppsala, Sweden) using AM. In particular, VBN has successfully developed a series of ultrahard steels that have demonstrated extreme wear and thermal resistance that could potentially offer improved performance and component lifetime. The superior performance of these alloys was achieved through a combination of compositional designs as well as optimization of annealing treatments. Furthermore, VBN has developed proprietary AM-based processing routines that enable the production of near-net shape components from the entire range of alloys.
Various sample types produced from three different alloys were procured from VBN Components in the fully annealed and surface ground conditions (e.g., ready to test conditions). Analytical microscopy indicated that all three alloys contained an appreciable amount of various micronsized carbides. The presence of these carbides resulted in the steels having ultrahigh strengths and overall hardness but at the cost of a reduced level of tensile ductility. This observation was further confirmed in the wear and tensile results.
Based upon the various results, it was determined that the alloys lacked the required toughness (ductility) for use in high strain-rate and/or impact-related applications. Instead, the alloys showed significant promise in wear resistance applications. Indeed, Alloy Vibenite 280 was found to have similar overall properties (mechanical, wear resistance, and corrosion) as alloy AISI 52100 and thus could be a potential substitute for this alloy, with the noted benefit of being produced via current AM methods. This ability could enable the potential redesign of existing parts to save weight or improve performance by leveraging production features possible in AM methods that are not available in conventional metal-forming operations.
This work was performed by Vincent Hammond and a team of other researchers for the Army Research Laboratory (Aberdeen, MD). For more information, download the Technical Support Package (free white paper) below. ADTTSP-05244
This Brief includes a Technical Support Package (TSP).

Evaluation of Additively Manufactured Ultrahard Steels
(reference ADTTSP-05244) is currently available for download from the TSP library.
Don't have an account?
Overview
The document titled "Evaluation of Additively Manufactured Ultrahard Steels" is a technical report that presents the findings of a study conducted by a team from the DEVCOM Army Research Laboratory. The report covers the evaluation of ultrahard steels produced through additive manufacturing techniques, focusing on their mechanical properties, microstructural characteristics, and performance in various tests.
The report is structured into several key sections, beginning with an introduction that outlines the significance of ultrahard steels in military and industrial applications. The authors emphasize the advantages of additive manufacturing, such as the ability to create complex geometries and reduce material waste, which can lead to significant cost and time savings compared to traditional manufacturing methods.
In the materials section, the report details the specific alloys and manufacturing processes used in the study. The authors conducted a series of experiments to assess the density, hardness, and microstructural properties of the additively manufactured steels. The results are presented in various subsections, including mechanical testing for tension, tension-tension fatigue, and quasi-static and high-rate compression. These tests are crucial for understanding the performance of the materials under different loading conditions.
The report also includes a section on wear and corrosion testing, which evaluates the durability and longevity of the materials in practical applications. The findings indicate that the additively manufactured ultrahard steels exhibit promising wear resistance and corrosion performance, making them suitable for demanding environments.
Computed tomography (CT) analysis is employed to provide insights into the internal structure of the materials, revealing any defects or inconsistencies that may affect performance. The report concludes with a summary of the key findings, highlighting the potential of these materials for future applications in defense and other industries.
Overall, the document serves as a comprehensive evaluation of the advancements in ultrahard steel production through additive manufacturing, showcasing the potential benefits and applications of these materials. The research is supported by funding from the Office of the Secretary of Defense, underscoring its relevance to national defense and technological innovation. The report is approved for public release, ensuring that the findings can contribute to broader knowledge in the field.
Top Stories
INSIDERDesign
Venus Aerospace’s Rotating Detonation Rocket Engine Completes First Flight...
INSIDERDesign
Bombardier is Digitally Upgrading its Aircraft Design, Engineering and...
INSIDERDefense
How the US Army is Advancing Research in Robotics, AI and Autonomy
INSIDERManned Systems
New Copper Alloy Could Provide Breakthrough in Durability for Military Systems
Original EquipmentManned Systems
ACT Expo 2025: Heavy-Duty EVs, H2 Trucks and Tariff Talk Dominate Day One
Technology ReportPower
Webcasts
Defense
Soar to New Heights: Simulation-Driven Design for Safety in Electrified...
Software
Improving Signal and Power Integrity Performance in Automotive...
Aerospace
Transforming Quality Management with Data-Driven Analytics
Software
Enhancing Automotive Software Efficiency with vECU-based...
Aerospace
Precision Under Pressure: The Centerless Grinding Advantage in...
Photonics/Optics
Breaking Barriers in Space Communication with Optical Technology